Kohl&Blush
CoverGirl Blackest Black MascaraCoverGirl Blackest Black Mascara (view 2)CoverGirl Blackest Black Mascara (view 3)

Mascara · Eyes

CoverGirl Blackest Black Mascara

by CoverGirl · #18 of 19 in mascara

CoverGirl Blackest Black Mascara is a solid budget-friendly option for anyone wanting bold, dark lashes without clumping or smudging throughout the day.

4.2
Editor scoreVery good
  • Volume8.3
  • Length7.7
  • Smudge resistance8.8
  • Value for money8.4
  • Intense blackest black color
  • Smudge-resistant all-day wear
  • Budget-friendly volume and length
Check price on Amazon

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Price and availability are shown on Amazon.

Overview

CoverGirl Blackest Black Mascara delivers exactly what its name promises: an intensely pigmented, ultra-dark formula designed to drench lashes in deep, saturated color from root to tip. Unlike mascaras that offer a diluted or slightly brownish-black finish, this formula is engineered to achieve the deepest black possible, giving lashes a dramatic, high-contrast look that makes eyes appear more striking and awake. The pigment-rich formula coats each lash evenly, ensuring there are no patchy or translucent spots, which is especially important for anyone wanting a bold, defined eye look for both everyday wear and special occasions.

The brush design plays a crucial role in how this mascara performs, typically featuring bristles that are closely spaced to grab even the shortest and finest lashes while distributing the pigment-heavy formula smoothly. This helps prevent clumping, a common complaint with heavily pigmented mascaras, while still building noticeable volume and length with just a few swipes. Many users appreciate that the wand allows for both subtle definition when applied lightly and a more voluminous, false-lash-like effect when layered, making it versatile enough to suit different makeup styles and intensities depending on the occasion.

Affordable and widely accessible, CoverGirl Blackest Black Mascara has become a drugstore staple for those seeking a budget-friendly alternative to high-end mascaras without sacrificing pigment intensity. Its formula is designed to hold a curl throughout the day, resisting smudging and flaking under normal wear conditions, which makes it a practical choice for long workdays or nights out. For makeup enthusiasts who prioritize bold, dark lash color as the foundation of their eye makeup routine, this mascara offers a reliable, no-fuss way to achieve that signature deep black intensity without a hefty price tag.

Key features

  • Intensely pigmented blackest black formula
  • Flexible wand for volume and length
  • Smudge-resistant, long-wearing formula
  • Conditioning ingredients to help prevent clumping
  • Buildable formula for natural to dramatic looks
  • Ophthalmologist tested, safe for sensitive eyes

Specifications

Net Weight
0.44 fl oz (13 ml)
Formula Type
Water-based, non-waterproof
Brush Type
Flexible curved wand
Finish
Bold matte black
Skin Type Suitability
Ophthalmologist tested, sensitive eyes

What we love

  • Delivers true deep black color payoff
  • Affordable drugstore price point
  • Adds noticeable volume and length
  • Easy to apply without clumping
  • Holds curl throughout the day
  • Widely available at drugstores and mass retailers

What to know

  • Can flake slightly by end of day for some users
  • Not fully waterproof in humid conditions
  • Brush can be slightly large for lower lashes
  • Formula may dry out faster than premium brands
  • Removal can require extra effort with oil-based remover
4.2out of 5

The verdict

CoverGirl Blackest Black Mascara is a solid budget-friendly option for anyone wanting bold, dark lashes without clumping or smudging throughout the day. While it isn't fully waterproof and may flake slightly after long wear, its intense pigment, buildable formula, and affordable price make it a reliable everyday mascara choice.

Check price on Amazon
Blackest Black MascaraEditor score 4.2/5Check price